2024 Midseason Top 100 Prospects

In recent years, we have had more evaluators contribute to the Top 100 list. However, this year we have decided to combine Matt Thompson and Rhys White's lists to create the midseason Top 100 list. This update reflects how we view the prospects as things stand, with their fit within their organizations to be reflected at a later time.

We have included the 2024 draftees in this updated version, with the assumption that everyone here will sign and play some form of affiliated baseball this season for the team that drafted them. This year’s draft was not known for its strength or depth, leading to a record low number of recent draftees making the midseason list. It is not easy to properly assess how recent college players will slot into their respective organizations, but we believe we did a good job of comparing them to their new peers. Evaluating high school/prep talent through the same prism is harder, but we are confident in the way we stacked them up against other fellow minor leaguers.

There was no debate for the top prospect this year; it was clearly James Wood, who provides eye-popping power and more than enough plate skills to make us confident in him atop our list. He has overtaken Jackson Holliday for us. While we believe Holliday will be a really good major leaguer and have him right behind Wood, we are more confident in Wood being the better player short and long-term. Rhys and Matt had a pretty similar top 10, with Dylan Crews and Junior Caminero being flipped on their lists. The same goes for Samuel Basallo and Jackson Jobe, who were also flip-flopped on their respective lists.

The biggest riser this year is recent major leaguer Jacob Wilson. He has hit the ground running this season, and a year after being drafted, he is now a big leaguer. He has shown that minor league pitching is no match for him. He doesn’t hit the ball hard, but he has enough power that opposing pitchers have to respect him. He is one of the highest-floor prospects to come out in a while and was fast-tracked through the Athletics’ system.

On the flip side, one of the biggest fallers is Colson Montgomery. He is still a top 60 prospect for us, but he was viewed as someone who was going to break into the top 10. Things for him as a hitter have gone backward. He isn’t hitting like he has before this season, and his power has taken a step back as well. The encouraging development in Montgomery’s game is that he has taken a big step forward as a shortstop defender. However, the building blocks of his skill set have regressed this season, pushing him down our list.

It is important to note that the minor leagues as a whole are weaker. This is a result of several factors. Teams are more aggressive than ever in promoting prospects to the majors. Plus, we have a cutdown of the minor league spots in general, lessening the pool. This is one of the weaker crops of top 100 prospects in recent memory.

All this to say, here is the Prospects Live Midseason Top 100 Prospects list.

1. James Wood, OF Washington Nationals

Highest Level: MLB | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 10

2. Jackson Holliday, SS/2B Baltimore Orioles

Highest Level: MLB | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 1

3. Junior Caminero, 3B Tampa Bay Rays

Highest Level: Triple-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 4

4. Dylan Crews, OF Washington Nationals

Highest Level: Triple-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 6

5. Samuel Basallo, C Baltimore Orioles

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 7

6. Jackson Jobe, RHP Detroit Tigers

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 13

7. Coby Mayo, 3B Baltimore Orioles

Highest Level: Triple-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 25

8. Carson Williams, SS Tampa Bay Rays

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 35

9. Jasson Dominguez, OF New York Yankees

Highest Level: MLB | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 27

10. Walker Jenkins, OF Minnesota Twins

Highest Level: Single-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 8

11. Brooks Lee, 3B Minnesota Twins

Highest Level: MLB | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 23

12. Noah Schultz, LHP Chicago White Sox

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 62

13. Andrew Painter, RHP Philadelphia Phillies

Highest Level: INJ | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 11

14. Marcelo Mayer, SS Boston Red Sox

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 36

15. Colt Emerson, SS Seattle Mariners

Highest Level: Single-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 41

16. Travis Bazzana, 2B Cleveland Guardians

Highest Level: NCAA | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: N/A

17. Jacob Wilson, SS Oakland Athletics

Highest Level: MLB | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

18. Lazaro Montes, OF Seattle Mariners

Highest Level: High-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 53

19. Xavier Isaac, 1B Tampa Bay Rays

Highest Level: High-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 74

20. Jordan Lawlar, SS Arizona Diamondbacks

Highest Level: Triple-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 15

21. Kyle Teel, C Boston Red Sox

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 45

22. Roman Anthony, OF Boston Red Sox

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 33

23. Charlie Condon, OF Colorado Rockies

Highest Level: NCAA | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: N/A

24. Emmanuel Rodriguez, OF Minnesota Twins

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 24

25. JJ Wetherholt, SS St. Louis Cardinals

Highest Level: NCAA | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: N/A

26. Tink Hence, RHP St. Louis Cardinals

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 81

27. Heston Kjerstad, OF Baltimore Orioles

Highest Level: MLB | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 61

28. Chase Dollander, RHP Colorado Rockies

Highest Level: High-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 60

29. Adael Amador, 2B Colorado Rockies

Highest Level: MLB | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 21

30. Kevin McGonigle, SS/2B Detroit Tigers

Highest Level: Single-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

31. Cole Young, SS/2B Seattle Mariners

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 38

32. Chase Burns, RHP Cincinnati Reds

Highest Level: NCAA | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: N/A

33. Aidan Miller, SS Philadelphia Phillies

Highest Level: High-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

34. Cade Horton, RHP Chicago Cubs

Highest Level: Triple-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 17

35. Hagen Smith, LHP Chicago White Sox

Highest Level: NCAA | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: N/A

36. Owen Caissie, OF Chicago Cubs

Highest Level: Triple-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 68

37. Max Clark, OF Detroit Tigers

Highest Level: Single-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 30

38. Dalton Rushing, C Los Angeles Dodgers

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 63

39. Ethan Salas, C San Diego Padres

Highest Level: High-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 12

40. Bubba Chandler, RHP Pittsburgh Pirates

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 76

41. Matt Shaw, 3B/2B Chicago Cubs

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 29

42. Quinn Mathews, LHP St. Louis Cardinals

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

43. Spencer Jones, OF New York Yankees

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 32

44. Ralphy Velazquez, 1B Cleveland Guardians

Highest Level: Single-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

45. Sebastian Walcott, SS/3B Texas Rangers

Highest Level: High-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 99

46. Bryce Eldridge, 1B San Francisco Giants

Highest Level: High-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 64

47. Moises Ballesteros, C/1B Chicago Cubs

Highest Level: Triple-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

48. Jacob Misiorowski, RHP Milwaukee Brewers

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 40

49. Luke Keaschall, 2B Minnesota Twins

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

50. Brandon Sproat, RHP New York Mets

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

51. Colson Montgomery, SS Chicago White Sox

Highest Level: Triple-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 18

52. Thomas White, LHP Miami Marlins

Highest Level: High-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

53. Rhett Lowder, RHP Cincinnati Reds

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 52

54. Jett Williams, SS New York Mets

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 34

55. Chase DeLauter, OF Cleveland Guardians

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 31

56. Starlyn Caba, SS Philadelphia Phillies

Highest Level: CPX | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

57. Kyle Manzardo, 1B Cleveland Guardians

Highest Level: MLB | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 69

58. Angel Genao, SS Cleveland Guardians

Highest Level: High-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

59. Justin Crawford, OF Philadelphia Phillies

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

60. David Festa, RHP Minnesota Twins

Highest Level: MLB | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

61. Zebby Matthews, RHP Minnesota Twins

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

62. Jac Caglianone, 1B/LHP Kansas City Royals

Highest Level: NCAA | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

63. Leodalis De Vries, SS San Diego Padres

Highest Level: Single-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 71

64. Josue De Paula, OF Los Angeles Dodgers

Highest Level: High-A| 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 50

65. Braden Montgomery, OF Boston Red Sox

Highest Level: NCAA | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: N/A

66. Jonny Farmelo, OF Seattle Mariners

Highest Level: Single-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

67. Drew Gilbert, OF New York Mets

Highest Level: Triple-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 48

68. Caden Dana, RHP Los Angeles Angels

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

69. Brayden Taylor, SS/3B Tampa Bay Rays

Highest Level: High-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

70. Max Meyer, RHP Miami Marlins

Highest Level: MLB | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

71. Jefferson Rojas, SS Chicago Cubs

Highest Level: high-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

72. Jace Jung, 3B/2B Detroit Tigers

Highest Level: Triple-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 91

73. Jeferson Quero, C Milwaukee Brewers

Highest Level: Triple-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 44

74. Felnin Celesten, SS Seattle Mariners

Highest Level: CPX | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

75. Jaison Chourio, OF Cleveland Guardians

Highest Level: Single-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

76. Tyler Black, 1B Milwaukee Brewers

Highest Level: MLB | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 70

77. Victor Scott II, OF St. Louis Cardinals

Highest Level: MLB | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 47

78. Luis Morales, RHP Oakland Athletics

Highest Level: High-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

79. Agustin Ramirez, C New York Yankees

Highest Level: Triple-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

80. Emiliano Teodo, RHP Texas Rangers

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

81. Santiago Suarez, RHP Tampa Bay Rays

Highest Level: Single-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

82. Bryce Rainer, SS Detroit Tigers

Highest Level: HS | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: N/A

83. Konnor Griffin, OF Pittsburgh Pirates

Highest Level: HS | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: N/A

84. Chandler Simpson, OF Tampa Bay Rays

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

85. Brock Wilken, 3B Milwaukee Brewers

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 72

86. Justin Wrobleski, LHP Los Angeles Dodgers

Highest Level: MLB | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

87. Cade Povich, LHP Baltimore Orioles

Highest Level: MLB | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

88. Edgar Quero, C Chicago White Sox

Highest Level: Triple-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 100

89. Kristian Campbell, 3B Boston Red Sox

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

90. Cooper Pratt, SS Milwaukee Brewers

Highest Level: Single-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

91. Brady House, 3B Washington Nationals

Highest Level: Triple-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 66

92. C.J. Kayfus, 1B Cleveland Guardians

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

93. George Klassen, RHP Philadelphia Phillies

Highest Level: High-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

94. Termarr Johnson, 2B Pittsburgh Pirates

Highest Level: High-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 42

95. Henry Bolte, OF Oakland Athletics 

Highest Level: Double-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

96. Alfredo Duno, C Cincinnati Reds

Highest Level: Single-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

97. Thayron Liranzo, C Los Angeles Dodgers

Highest Level: High-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 97

98. Drew Thorpe, RHP Chicago White Sox

Highest Level: MLB | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: 43

99. Nacho Alvarez Jr., SS/3B Atlanta Braves

Highest Level: Triple-A | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

100. Hayden Birdsong, RHP San Francisco Giants

Highest Level: MLB | 2024 Preseason Top 100 Rank: UNRANKED

MLB Draft Live Looks Week 8 - Southern California and New York

In this edition of MLB Draft Live looks, Brandon Smith and Jackson Thomas went out and saw front-line 2022 draft talent including big pop-up prospects at the high school and college level.

RHP RILEY KELLY, TUSTIN HS

Seen: 4/13

Riley Kelly a UCI commit out of Tustin High School has been a sudden pop-up pitcher for the upcoming draft. What fueled the pop-up hype was reports that his fastball was up to 92-94 on a consistent basis. However, during this outing, he was predominantly 88-90 and hit 91 only once. Additionally, his fastball came off rather pedestrian in shape and life, consistently coming in straight with occasional arm side life. Regardless of Kelly’s fastball, there was plenty of intriguing projectability and skillset that hold merit to him being a pop-up guy. Kelly has a large projectable frame with long limbs and a slender build, boding well for future added muscle and strength. He works downhill with his delivery with little bend and flexibility coming from tightly wound hips, forcing him to pitch from an upright stance with little leg drive. Kelly repeats his short arm action well with good arm speed, a snappy finish, and solid extension. The biggest takeaway from Kelly’s outing was that he can spin the breaking ball, which was a large part of his 17 K performance. The curveball projects as a future 55/60 pitch with tight spin and big 11/5 shape that was consistently landed for a strike in any count at 77-80 MPH. All in all, it is easy to see all the projection that Kelly has as a pitching prospect. It wouldn’t be a surprise to see him taken on late Day 2 of the draft but I believe that he could see his development skyrocket by going to UCI. 

- Jackson Thomas

RHP DREW THORPE, CAL POLY SLO

Seen: 4/14

Performance: 6 IP, 3 H, 3 ER, 9 K, 2 BB, 33.98% CSW

Cal Poly’s Drew Thorpe, #93 on @ProspectsLive 2022 Draft Board, is through 2 IP with 3 Ks and has given up 1 R on 1 H. The change up is showing out with late bite and has 3 whiffs so far. Heavy CH usage early on pic.twitter.com/plMOS9w7yv

— Jackson Thomas (@BaseballByJT) April 15, 2022

Drew Thorpe continued his dominant season with a good outing against the UCI Anteaters. Thrope has generated a lot of buzz in California for his consistent performance, projectability, and ability to throw 3+ pitches for strikes. He repeats his delivery well showing lots of athleticism to drive down the bump and push out over his chest. His arm action overall was very clean and smooth, coming from a small tight circle path to a high 3/4 release. The Mustangs’ ace leaned heavily on his change-up all night, arguably his best pitch with flashes of plus. The changeup moves with late lateral fade, falling off as soon as it gets near home plate, sitting 78-81 MPH. His changeup had a 50% whiff rate on the outing and Thorpe demonstrated high confidence in using that weapon in any count. Thrope’s fastball topped out at 93 and was mainly in the 89-91 range as the night progressed. He showed the ability to command his fastball and all edges of the zone, using its sinking profile to his advantage. Thrope’s slider was used as his third pitch and generated its share of whiffs, coming in with a tight and short 10/4 break at 79-81 MPH. A common theme for Thorpe on his outing was that he consistently battled from behind in counts to generate outs, which is great to see he can compete even without having his best stuff. 

- Jackson Thomas

SS BROOKS LEE, CAL POLY SLO

Seen: 4/14, 4/15

Performance: 2-7, 1 RBI, 1 K, 2 BB, 1 SB

Arguably the top college draft prospect for the 2022 class had a relatively quiet two games in my looks, only getting two hits, with one being an IF single. Regardless it’s apparent to see why Lee is a projected top 5 pick. Lee has a maxed-out build with tree trunk legs and a strong upper half. He is able to fully integrate his body into his swing, fully complimenting his great bat speed and above-average bat-to-ball skills. When running out of the box Lee showed good acceleration down the baseline but didn’t reach a top line speed that was anything to write home about. Lee made a good read on a breaking ball to get a stolen base with ease on Friday’s game, once again showing high-level intangibles and baseball intellect on the diamond.. I will question how long Lee can stay at SS considering his range seemed limited to his right side on a couple of ground balls that snuck through with slow and choppy footwork. However, Lee has the ideal makeup for a pro player as he consistently plays with high levels of poise, leadership, and confidence on the diamond.

- Jackson Thomas

RHP NOLAN DEVOS, DAVIDSON

Seen: 4/15

Performance: 5.2 IP, 8 H, 3 ER, 1 BB, 7 K 

DeVos has been somewhat of a popup prospect this spring for Davidson after he was a walk-on his freshman year. He consistently has been one of the nations leaders in strikeouts throughout the spring season. This is due to his above average fastball/slider mix which generates whiffs in all quadrants of the zone. DeVos has a deceptive operation that analytically driven teams covet, as he releases from a lower release height and still creates lift on his four seam fastball up in the zone. This was displayed during his outing as he was able to attack Bonaventure hitters up in the zone and generated whiffs. His fastball sat in the 89-92 range, which is a couple of ticks down from earlier in the year when he would sit in the mid 90s. It is important to note that he has been primarily used as a reliever during his collegiate career and the additional workload may be a factor for the slight decrease in velocity. Additionally, he had to battle suboptimal weather conditions as there were 40mph winds as well as precipitation factored in with below 40 degree weather.  He showed excellent command of his sweeping slider which darted away from right handed hitters and was not afraid to triple up on the offering. He also dropped in a couple of curveballs or “dumpers” early in counts to work ahead of hitters, as well as flashing a changeup to left-hand hitters. The only blemish on his line came when he left a fastball up over the heart of the plate to a right handed hitter who was able to get on plane and drive the pitch over the left field wall. Despite the long ball, he rebounded nicely to strikeout the next two batters he faced. DeVos worked from a very quick tempo on the hill and was very efficient with his pitches as he made quick use of hitters and rarely worked deep counts. There is a lot to like in the analytical profile with DeVos and if he can show that he can gain back some of his velocity, he figures to hear his name called in the 8-10 round range. 

- Brandon Smith

CF PARKER NOLAN, DAVIDSON

Seen: 4/15

Performance: 2-5, 1 HR, 1 1B, 1 K

Nolan is a toolsy outfielder and will be a name to monitor late on day three. Despite being a four year player, Nolan’s game still is raw.  Standing in at 6’4, he showed his defense, speed, and power tools . He gets great reads off the bat in centerfield and uses his speed to track down fly balls in the gaps as he has great closing speed. He showed the power tool when he unloaded on a go-ahead three run homerun in his final at-bat that he blasted to his pull side.  There are questions surrounding his bat to ball skills and whether or not he will make enough contact to ascend through a minor league system. Nonetheless, the raw skills and athleticism Nolan possesses would make him an interesting prospect if an organization feels that they can develop his raw skill set into more polished tools. 

- Brandon Smith

C MICHAEL CARICO (2023), DAVIDSON

Seen: 4/15

Performance: 1-3, 1 1B, 2 BB 

Never too early to look ahead to the 2023 class and Davidson appears to have a name to follow in Michael Carico. The left-hand hitting catcher is very poised in the box. Carico demonstrates advanced feel for the strike and recognizes spin well. This is reflective in his swing decisions and in his walk rate.  A byproduct of his selective approach at the plate is his ability to punish pitches in the zone. He has a quiet load as works into his backside and has a quick bat path which allows him to barrel pitches. He showed power to all fields during his pregame batting practice and has hit homers to all fields in game. Carico is an athletic catcher who moves well behind the plate. There is still plenty of projection remaining in his game with his hit and power tool grading out well above average.

- Brandon Smith